White Bird American Movie Review

“White Bird” is a heartfelt narrative about compassion amid the horrors of Nazi brutality, adapted from R.J. Palacio’s YA graphic novel, Wonder Story. Set mostly in a historical context, the film stars Helen Mirren in a distinguished role as Grandmère, a renowned artist and a Jewish woman reflecting on her past. Grandmère shares her emotional story with her grandson, Julian Albans (played by Bryce Gheisar), a high schooler suspended for bullying. Through her tale, she recounts her survival during Hitler’s pogrom in Nazi-occupied France, focusing on how a courageous French family and their son, Julien, risked their lives to hide and protect her. Despite the film’s powerful message of kindness and sacrifice, Julian’s transformation feels somewhat contrived, failing to elicit the deep emotional response one might expect from such a poignant story.

White Bird American Movie Review

White Bird American Movie Plot Summary:

YouTube (Lionsgate Movies)

White Bird is a poignant adaptation of the young adult graphic novel Wonder Story by R.J. Palacio, unfolding against the backdrop of Nazi-occupied France. The story juxtaposes two timelines — one of Sara Blum (Ariella Glaser), a Jewish girl who finds refuge with a French family, and the other of her older self, Grandmère Sara (Helen Mirren), recounting her harrowing survival story to her grandson Julian Albans (Bryce Gheisar). After being suspended from school for bullying, Julian’s life changes as Grandmère Sara shares her past, illustrating the kindness she experienced during the Nazi regime. Through her story, Julian learns lessons of compassion, humanity, and the importance of standing up against injustice.

White Bird American Movie Cast:

Ariella Glaser as Sara Blum: A young Jewish girl hiding from the Nazis in a French barn.
Orlando Schwerdt as Julien Beaumier: Sara’s polio-stricken classmate who, with his family, risks their lives to shelter Sara.
Bryce Gheisar as Julian Albans: Sara’s grandson, who is struggling with his own issues at school.
Gillian Anderson as Vivienne Beaumier: Julien’s mother, who plays a critical role in protecting Sara.
Helen Mirren as Grandmère Sara: The older version of Sara, now a renowned artist, reflecting on her past.
Patsy Ferran as Mlle Petitjean: Sara and Julien’s teacher.
Stuart McQuarrie as Pastor Luc: The headmaster of Sara and Julien’s school.

White Bird American Movie Review:

Marc Forster’s White Bird is a sincere attempt to adapt a heartwarming and tragic story of survival during one of history’s darkest times. The film alternates between two timelines: Sara’s story of hiding from the Nazis and her grandson Julian’s struggle with school and bullying. The film effectively addresses themes of kindness, humanity, and survival against the backdrop of Nazi atrocities.

The story begins with Julian’s suspension from school due to bullying, leading to Grandmère Sara’s unannounced visit. She shares her memories of Sara’s year in hiding with the Beaumier family, who risk their lives to protect her. The contrast between Sara’s war-torn youth and Julian’s school troubles is used as a narrative device, but it feels somewhat disjointed and lacks emotional resonance.

What Works:

Helen Mirren’s Gravitas: Helen Mirren brings a powerful presence to the screen in her role as Grandmère Sara, adding depth and complexity to the film. Her performance lends authenticity to the story and evokes sympathy for the characters.
Ariella Glaser’s Portrayal of Sara: Glaser embodies Sara’s vulnerability and resilience beautifully, making her the emotional core of the film. Her connection with Julien, played by Orlando Schwerdt, showcases a touching bond amid the horrors of war.
Cinematography: Matthias Koenigswieser’s cinematography is visually striking, with the carefully composed shots that depict both the intimate moments of Sara’s hiding and the vastness of the French countryside. The film takes on a storybook quality that suits its period setting.

What Doesn’t Work:

Weak Grandmother-Grandson Dynamic: The relationship between Grandmère Sara and Julian lacks emotional depth. The film’s attempt to juxtapose their stories feels superficial and forced, as the bond between the two is never convincingly developed.
Pacing Issues: The film’s dual timeline structure, while interesting, results in uneven pacing. The sections focused on Julian’s modern-day issues feel unnecessary and detract from Sara’s more compelling wartime story.
Contrived Plot Elements: Certain scenes, especially Julian’s sudden transformation after hearing his grandmother’s story, feel contrived and lack emotional weight. The film’s ending, while optimistic, comes off as overly manipulative.

White Bird American Movie Cast Performances:

Ariella Glaser delivers a standout performance as young Sara, bringing the character’s vulnerability and courage to life. She captures the fear and hope of a young girl navigating an uncertain world.
Orlando Schwerdt impresses as Julien Beaumier, portraying a complex character who is simultaneously fragile and brave.
Helen Mirren provides gravitas to her role as Grandmère Sara, though her screen time is relatively limited.
Gillian Anderson and Bryce Gheisar deliver competent performances, but their roles feel underdeveloped, with Anderson’s Vivienne remaining somewhat in the background.

White Bird American Movie Technical Aspects:

Direction: Marc Forster’s direction is earnest but lacks a certain fluidity. The film’s transition between timelines feels jarring at times, and the emotional impact suffers from the fragmented narrative structure.
Screenplay: Mark Bomback’s screenplay remains largely faithful to the source material, but the disjointed timelines and weak character development hinder the storytelling.
Music: Thomas Newman’s score complements the film’s emotional tone but doesn’t stand out as particularly memorable.

Verdict:

White Bird is a well-intentioned film that touches on important themes of kindness and humanity in the face of adversity. While it boasts strong performances and beautiful cinematography, the film is ultimately let down by its uneven pacing and underdeveloped character dynamics. It has its moments of emotional resonance, but it struggles to leave a lasting impact.

White Bird American Movie Director:

Director: Marc Forster.

White Bird American Movie Writer:

Writer: Mark Bomback.

White Bird American Movie Rating:

Rating: 2.5/5

Where to Watch White Bird American Movie:

White Bird is available in theaters as of October 4, 2024.

FAQs: (Frequently Asked Questions)

What is White Bird about?
White Bird is a film about a Jewish girl named Sara who hides from the Nazis in occupied France with the help of a kind French family. The film alternates between her past experiences and the present-day story of her grandson Julian, who learns valuable lessons from her survival story.
Is White Bird based on a book?
Yes, White Bird is based on R.J. Palacio’s graphic novel White Bird: A Wonder Story, which is a spin-off from her book Wonder.
Who stars in White Bird?
The film stars Helen Mirren, Ariella Glaser, Orlando Schwerdt, Bryce Gheisar, Gillian Anderson, and Patsy Ferran.
What themes are explored in the White Bird movie?
The film explores themes of kindness, survival, and standing up against injustice, set against the backdrop of Nazi-occupied France during World War II.
How long is White Bird?
The movie has a runtime of 120 minutes.
Is White Bird suitable for children?
White Bird is primarily targeted at a younger audience, aged between 8 and 16, though it contains mature themes related to war and persecution.
What is the message of White Bird?
The film conveys a message about the importance of kindness and bravery in the face of cruelty and injustice, emphasizing how small acts of goodness can make a difference during dark times.
Who directed White Bird?
The film is directed by Marc Forster, known for his previous works such as Finding Neverland and The Kite Runner.
Is White Bird connected to the movie Wonder?
Yes, White Bird is a spin-off from the movie Wonder, centering on a character introduced in the original story.
Where can I watch White Bird?
White Bird is currently playing in theaters.